From 64 soundtracks to just two critically acclaimed masterpieces. Prince’s collection of new material for Purple Rain set a new precedent for soundtracks featuring an artist or band. It was a top seed because it has been recognized time and time again as not only an excellent soundtrack, but a solid album by a straight-up pop/rock music royalty. Still, this was no easy journey. In order to arrive here, Purple Rain had to earn your votes against a New Jack City compilation, The Beatles, Aimee Mann, and finally, the great and beloved Whitney Houston. Most recently it won in an epic battle against surprise upsetter, Catch Me If You Can.
Prince’s contender is O Brother, Where Art Thou, a more recent soundtrack that has been recognized for the way it brought old-timey country into the mainstream and reminded the world exactly why Alison Krauss is the most Grammy-winning female of all time. It competed with the musical soundtracks, having to go up against nostalgic family-favourites such Frozen, Grease, Wizard of Oz, and finally The Sound of Music. In the Final 4, the fight was with the 90’s classic, Romeo + Juliet, but O Brother was still able to prevail, with more votes than any poll in the Soundtrack Madness brackets.
The choice is yours. I’d love to hear the reasoning behind your vote as well, so feel free to say your piece in the comments. I’ll give a play-by-play listen/blog of the champion soundtrack, so check back next week for the winner. I’ll keep this poll open until Sunday, April 19th. May the best album win!
Before we begin to vote, a brief caveat is necessary. You might have already noticed that not all the soundtracks in this bracket are strictly musicals. Classic musicals are here in this bracket, along with films that feature songs actually sung by cast members as part of the plot. Albums in this bracket are all made up of songs performed and recorded by the bulk of the film’s cast. Although this means that the songs are even more tied up with the characters that sing them, please remember to vote for the soundtrack itself, and not for the movie, as difficult as it may be to make that distinction.
West Side Story (1) vs. Once (16)
I’m sorry. And the choices do not get any easier from here. With Shakespeare as their muse, Bernstein and Sondheim combine powers to create the album that held onto the Billboard #1 spot for the longest run in history. West Side Story goes up against one of the most beautiful collaborations of the last 10 years that has inspired a broadway musical and given the stars Glen Hansard and Marketa Iglova (who are both musicians before they are actors) a chance to tour together as The Swell Season. I know who I will vote for, but that doesn’t mean it won’t be painful.
Sound of Music (9) vs. Singin’ In The Rain (8)
Two classics that have only grown in their popularity and influence will face off here. It has been hard for me to find a copy of Singin’ In the Rain that doesn’t rely on film clips, which could either hurt or help it depending on how people feel about the broadway style of dance. I thought I had a fair amount of nostalgia tied up with The Sound of Music, but when Julie Andrews walked on stage at the Oscars and people in the room watching with me burst into tears, I realized that some folks have an even deeper attachment. I suppose this will be one type of nostalgia against another.
Blues Brothers (5) vs. The Commitments (12)
Which group of soul-singing white men will you choose: The SNL sketch-turned-revivalist movement that drew a fan base extending way beyond the film; or a collection of covers by Irish youth, creating a fusion of two cultural souls expressing their humanity under oppression? At bare minimum, these are two great collections of reinterpreted soul songs.
Moulin Rouge (13) vs. Hedwig and the Angry Inch (4)
Moulin Rouge is what happens when a compilation soundtrack is performed by the characters. Familiar songs by Elton John, David Bowie and The Police are given a rebirth into a turn-of-the-century Parisian context. It seems somewhat appropriate that the cabaret-set Moulin Rouge goes up against Hedwig and the Angry Inch, the music from a transgender performer that has gained a massive cult following and is now back on broadway with Neil Patrick Harris as its lead.
Wizard of Oz (3) vs. Inside Llewan Davis (14)
I have no idea how to compare these two soundtracks. The Wizard of Oz Soundtrack was released in 1956, seventeen years after the film, and is as classic a musical as this bracket gets. Inside Llewyn Davis was released in 2013, making it the most recent album in the Soundtrack March Madness, though the music is mostly 60’s folk tune covers.
Wild Style (11) vs. This is Spinal Tap (6)
Wild Style is not a documentary, but it acts like a time capsule for early hip hop as both the film and soundtrack are stacked with pioneers like Fab 5 Freddy and the Cold Crush Brothers. Spinal Tap is a mockumentary with a strong cult following, and although the metal band is fictional, the album has found success as both soundtrack and satire.
Mary Poppins (7) vs. Grease (10)
Well these albums certainly hit two very different parts of my childhood, how about yours? Julie Andrews continues to have inexplicable powers over much of the world. Grease takes us back to our youth, regardless of whether we were youth in the 50’s, 70’s or 90’s.
O Brother, Where Art Thou (2) vs. Frozen (15)
Not only is Frozen the most recent album (along with Inside Llewyn Davis) in these brackets, it’s also the only soundtrack to a fully animated film. No other soundtrack in the past ten years has broken so many records both on Billboard and in sales, so it seemed appropriate to give it its chance here in March Madness as well. O Brother is a collection of traditional and modern bluegrass and country songs, many of which are performed by the Soggy Bottom Boys in the film, and it is addicting. It also heavily features Grammy darling (winner of 27 trophies!), Alison Krauss.
I have a bone to pick. I can’t completely decide who it’s with exactly, but contenders include Rolling Stone magazine, music critics in general, and the culture of popular music.
Perhaps you would like a bit of context. Some of you may know by now that I am a bit of a list-o-phile. Usually I like my lists to be specific enough to make sense, but open-ended enough to have to make tough decisions, such as the greatest ______ of a particular genre or time period. But every once in a while I love to spend some time in the vast lists that Rolling Stone enjoys dropping. Recently a coworker and I made a competition out of seeing whose iTunes library included more of their “500 Greatest Songs of All-Time”. (By the way, I won the competition, so this is not the response of a bitter loser). The list was not nearly as sweeping as it claimed, completely ignoring anything before 1957 and barely entering our present decade or the one before it. I won’t even bother with that list here, but it did get me curious about their similarly titled list of albums, which I quickly found some issues with.
Out of 500 albums spanning from the 1950’s to now, and across the genre spectrum from Country to Rap, Soul to Psychadelic Rock, those with female participation in bands or as solo artists make up 13%. If I were to add only those by either solo female artists and bands with front women, it would be below 10% with 45 artists. 45! out of 500! See the whole thing HERE.
Now, I recognize that Rolling Stone magazine is about as sausage-festy as magazines get, but it is also one of the most well-respected publications in popular music, and is, at the moment, the driving force in writing our pop music history. So, is it the fault of listeners and buyers of music that success is only given to male solo artists, or all-male bands? Or, is it the fault of these panels of judges, who write articles and best-of lists, painting our perception of greatness with a brush of testosterone?
And so I’d like to lead you on a scavenger hunt for great albums by female artists that seem to be missing from Rolling Stone’s list. Seeing as I have a tendency to specify lists in some way, we’ll look at one genre at a time. First of all, is there anything missing from the world of jazz and blues, music that has indeed paved the way for all modern pop music? Miles Davis is there, John Coltrane is there, even Frank Sinatra showed up for the party! Then, surely Ella will make an appearance, even if only alongside Louis Armstrong, and Billie Holiday should be expected at some point with a live recording or a best-of! I dare you to try to find either of their names anywhere. With the possible (but not justified) argument that Ella and Billie were not writing or producing their albums, an even more stark omission is Nina Simone, who wrote music for more than 40 albums in her lifetime, and continues to be constantly quoted, referenced, covered, and sampled all over the place in hiphop and pop.
Those are just the obvious, but in a list of 500 I might also expect to see Mahalia Jackson, one of the greatest gospel voices to hear on vinyl, or Bessie Smith the “Empress of Blues” who inspired all of the above, and who also inspired many blues artists (male and female) who did make the list. I would also implore consideration of Alice Coltrane’s Journey in Satchindananda, one of a few jazz records where the front woman is not a vocalist, but a pianist and harpist. Still, it’s possible that we know of her by the celebrity of her husband. Newer women of jazz and blues could include Norah Jones, Cassandra Wilson, or Natalie Cole.
R&B/Soul is represented relatively well on this list by the likes of some expected (ie. Aretha, Dusty Springfield’s Dusty in Memphis and Diana Ross & The Supremes) and some surprises (ie. TLC, Whitney Houston, and Mary J Blige). I’m not going to lie, I loved the fact that Janet charts with both Rhthym Nation and Velvet Rope. Many additions I would make would have more to do with a need for updating (the list was published in 2003), to include newer records such as Amy Winehouse’s Back to Black, Janelle Monae’s Archandroid, or nearly anything by Sharon Jones. At this point I might even venture to suggest Beyonce’s 4, but are you really surprised? Still, others cannot be excused by time, because 3 years is certainly enough to recognize the force and beauty of Erykah Badu’s Mama’s Gun, which is nowhere to be found in the 500. Not to mention the mature and smouldering Lover’s Rock from british beauty, Sade, that came out the same year. Others that I wouldn’t mind seeing on the list might be Roberta Flack’s First Take or legendary Killing Me Softly, Gladys Knight’s Imagination, something from Jill Scott, or Tina Turner without the abusive Ike on Private Dancer.
I’m sure I could go on, but we’ll take a break and move along to Country and Folk. I don’t have a lot to say about Country music in general, and when it comes to albums, the few female-made records I would expect are here: collections of Dolly Parton, Patsy Cline, and Lucinda Williams’ Car Wheels on a Gravel Road. I do however, notice a lack of certain folk singer-songwriters. Joni Mitchell has some representation with Blue and Court and Spark, but I would add Hejira, For the Roses and maybe Clouds (If Randy Newman can chart with 3 albums, I think Joni Mitchell is entitled to at least one more). The Joans (Baez and Armatrading) are both missing entirely along with two incredibly prolific poets, Ani DiFranco and Kate Bush. They would have been well represented in my opinion by Not a Pretty Girl and Hounds of Love respectively, although they each have many additional album contenders. Tori Amos’ Little Earthquakes should probably be included, and maybe her Strange Little Girls as well. As singer-songwriters go, Tori offers not only well-written individual songs, but album contexts that invite us to find relationship between the songs.
Moving on to the genre that Rolling Stone loves most: good old Rock ‘n Roll. This genre makes up an overwhelming majority of the list, and is littered with multiple albums of The Beatles (with 11), The Rolling Stones (with 10) and Bruce Springsteen and The Who (with 8 each). I have no problem with classic rock – and I’ll freely admit to having a lot of this music, either on vinyl or mp3 – but it becomes overkill when a list so clearly wants to promote one kind of album to greatness, without considering albums that are the products of imagination and a desire to move the culture of pop music in a new direction. It also suggests to me a “golden age” of music (7 of the top 10 are from the 60’s), that doesn’t consider other influences and movements enough.
That being said, this rant is really only worth writing if it is true that there are indeed women making music as well as men. So who can replace an extraneous 60’s or 70’s British rock band record? I have a few suggestions.
Patti Smith finds herself in the top 50 (at #44) with Horses, but I would love to also see her more conceptually driven Easter, which fearlessly explores themes of the religious holiday, such as death and resurrection. I was certainly expecting some of my favorite female rockers, especially Ann and Nancy Wilson of Heart with Dreamboat Annie. “Crazy on You” was equally snubbed from RS’s 500 Greatest Songs, in my opinion, so I suppose we shouldn’t be shocked. I found myself scanning for either Pat Benatar or Joan Jett, who may have done more with singles, but so did a lot of men on the list. For some 90’s representation, I would have thought Sheryl Crow’s Tuesday Night Music Club could hold its own, having won Crow the first 3 of her 9 Grammys.
Annie Lennox shows up for the first and only time on the list at #500, and even then, only with the Eurythmics. I’m not entirely sure what that’s about, but wonder if the editors of Rolling Stone have heard album giants Diva and/or Medusa. Medusa is full of great songs written by men, many of which they consider to be “all-time greats”. Perhaps they feel threatened that a woman does these tracks so thoughtfully and originally.
Another one-hit-wonder on the list is Bjork, whose accessible Post is at #373, but her brilliant electronic masterpiece, Homogenic is left out. Homogenic is considered by many to be the best of electronic music, yet can’t even scrape into the top 500 albums of all time. If this is not an offense to women, it is an offense to the genre. As we’ve already moved into the world of pop, I can’t help but wonder about Mariah. In 2003, did we still love to hate her so much that we couldn’t take seriously anything she did in the 90’s? If so, it’s unfortunate. Say what you want about Mariah, but she has a more impressive range than nearly anyone on the list, and although it’s pop, she’s writing her own material. All the while in heels and a mini-skirt. Broadway divas such as Barbara Streisand and Judy Garland are also ignored, although each has at least one album that has been recognized by a Grammy.
Finally, let’s take a minute to talk about rap music. I will admit, there are not enough women in rap in general. However, there is only one woman recognized: Lauryn Hill at #312 with her Miseducation and #477 on The Fugee’s The Score, so even though they chose the best, they keep her above 300. I understand that there is not exactly a plethora of solo female rap artists putting out fantastic albums (and RS was probably patting themselves on the back for including any rap at all), but I seriously hoped for a bit of Missy Elliott, and crossed my fingers for a taste of Salt-n-Pepa. If they revisit the list, I would be floored if they fail to include M.I.A.’s Kala.
This is by no means a comprehensive list of women in music, but I hope it at least it reminds us that women are making music, even if male-critics like those at Rolling Stone don’t seem to recognize it. In the mean time, check out some of the artists I’ve mentioned. I made it easy to get started: all the pictures (and some of the words) link to performances on youtube.